Xenu-City.Net - One City. One Cult.OCCUPIED CLEARWATER
PICKET CHICKEN
"Scientology critics from Copenhagen to San Francisco walk the streets carrying signs that question the Dec. 5, 1995, death of McPherson in Clearwater. Some of those critics will be in Clearwater on the anniversary of her death again this year to picket Scientology buildings."

McPherson's death incites Web protests
St. Petersburg Times
, Nov. 14, 1998

Copyright Tilman Hausherr 1999
Richard Howd:
OSA agent and Picket Chicken
"Additional evidence showed that there had been other altercations between Scientologists and the Respondent at other Scientologist locations throughout the country. The Petitioner introduced these videotapes to show Respondent's violent propensities. However, these same videotapes clearly showed that as Respondent picketed in front of the various Scientology properties, Scientology members would close within 1 to 2 feet of the Respondent and the two would get 'in the face' of the other. They engaged in a type of 'picket chicken'."

Amended Temporary Injunction
Howd v. Minton
, Dec. 2, 1999

CONTENTS

Protests by Date

Flag Security Radio Frequencies
After a good videocamera, a radio scanner is the next most important thing to bring to a picket at the Flag Land Base.

More Links
Protests against Scientology around the country and around the world.

When Scientology's covert invasion of Clearwater was first revealed in the mid-70's, reaction from local residents was angry and vocal. The 1980 60 Minutes show, The Clearwater Conspiracy, shows former mayor Gabe Cazares speaking at a rather large demonstration against the cult.

Over the years, though, interest in public protest waned as Scientology quietly consolidated its economic power in the region, and new residents migrated to the area with no knowledge of or interest in the cult's local history.

Clearwater once again became the site of protests in March 1996, when Internet activists converged on the Flag Land Base in defiance of Scientology's attacks on ex-members, newsgroups, and websites. Demonstrations were also held that weekend at Scientology orgs around the globe, coordinated by the netizens on the newsgroup alt.religion.scientology.

By the end of 1996, the death of Lisa McPherson had become

 


DECEMBER 3-5, 1999

The most recent event maintained the tradition of new and different strategies on both sides of the field. The protesters held a free public conference for the first time, and the speaker list included former Clearwater Mayor Gabe Cazares, and former Scientologists Peter Alexander and David Cecere, and more. The cult's reaction to the demonstrations this year consisted of spending $1.4 million to tear up their own sidewalks. They also painted orange dots near their buildings to mark the 10-ft. distance that activist Bob Minton was required to maintain. The city reacted angrily to this defacement of public property, and ordered the Scientologists to clean up the dots.

  • A little friendliness may help acceptance
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 12, 1999
    "And quit hiring expensive lawyers to delve into people's past and confronting them with it. And quit tearing up sidewalks to deter your adversaries."
  • Scientology: An asset or liability for Clearwater?
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 8, 1999
    "In its effort to intimidate Minton and his followers and to limit their right to peaceful protest, the church showed it will spare no expense to silence its critics... No matter how much money the Church of Scientology brings to downtown Clearwater, it will be impossible for it to be an asset if it cannot control its harmful behavior."

  • Scientology foe moves in, digs in for a long fight
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 5, 1999
    "An opposition group to the Church of Scientology said Saturday it is well-financed and 'here to stay' with plans for a variety of activities, from speaking to school children and civic groups to counseling Scientologists about leaving their church. The group is called the Lisa McPherson Trust Inc., named for the 36-year-old Scientologist who died in 1995 while in the care of church staffers."

  • Church draws line for critics
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 4, 1999
    "Hundreds of bright orange dots decorated the public sidewalks and streets surrounding Scientology buildings in Clearwater on Friday, the work of church staffers with spray paint cans and measuring tapes... Minton's attorney, Denis deVlaming, compared the spray-painted markings to graffiti. Police Chief Sid Klein said the markings were 'defacing public property.' "

  • Scientology foes gather for 5th annual meeting
    Tampa Tribune, Dec. 4, 1999
    "The conference, now in its fifth year, has met with varied reaction from Scientology officials in the past - from angry confrontations to a counterpicket staged by Scientologists two years ago at the Clearwater Police Department."

  • Church staffer, foe told to stay apart
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 3, 1999
    "In an order Thursday, Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Judge Thomas E. Penick Jr. said Minton and Richard Howd, a Scientology staffer, "must be mutually restrained" after an altercation Halloween night. Minton must stay at least 10 feet away from 17 Scientology properties in Clearwater. And Howd must stay at least 20 feet from Minton."

  • Judge applies distance order to both Scientologist, critic
    Tampa Tribune, Dec. 3, 1999
    "Both sides claimed victory after Penick read his decision, but approximately 50 Scientologists sitting in the audience quickly left the courtroom while about 30 church critics cheered and stood around patting one another on the back."

  • Scientology work limits protesters
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 1, 1999
    "Ah, early December in downtown Clearwater. Light poles wrapped in red holiday ribbons. Trees along Cleveland Street abloom with tiny white lights. And, now, a newer tradition: the annual game of cat and mouse between the Church of Scientology and about two dozen of its most vocal critics, who for three years have gathered in Clearwater to stage protests on the anniversary of the Dec. 5, 1995, death of Scientologist Lisa McPherson."

Scientologists tear up their own sidewalks - Photo courtesy of Xenu TV

Scientologists scrubbing the sidewalk - Copyright Tilman Hausherr 1999


Bob Minton confronts Spencer, one of his Scientology "handlers"

Activist Bob Minton confronts Spencer, one of his Scientology "handlers", on Xenu TV

JULY 9, 1999

Bob Minton's counter-coastal surprise picket was the first to be covered by Mark Bunker's Xenu TV.


DECEMBER 4-6, 1998

The local backlash from Scientology's counter-protests probably caused their change in strategy for the December '98 demonstrations. This time, they abandoned the field completely, shuttling their members around in vans with darkened windows.

Picketing the Ft. Harrison Hotel

  • Picket Fencing
    Phoenix New Times, Jan. 21, 1999
    "Scientology critic Jeff Jacobsen helped get the church in hot water over a Florida death. Now, church members have figured out where he lives."
  • McPherson relatives lead protest
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 6, 1998
    "Saturday marked the first time McPherson's family had been to the Fort Harrison. They traveled from Texas for the ceremony, which also was attended by many of Scientology's most determined critics."
  • Scientologists steer clear of protest marking woman's death
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 6, 1998
    "At times, staffers were seen scurrying into church buildings, which were fortified in several ways. A 5-foot-high masonry wall surrounding much of Scientology's Fort Harrison Hotel was made 3 feet higher with temporary lattice and cardboard. A row of Christmas trees blocked views at another Scientology hotel. Many entrances were blocked from view."
  • Former Scientologist shares familiar tale of force feeding
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 5, 1998
    "A former Scientologist from Denmark said Friday that he helped force bread, fruit and liquids into the throat of an unconscious woman as part of an effort help her recover from a mental breakdown. Karsten Lorenzen's detailed account at a news conference held by a group of Scientology critics resembles the experience of Lisa McPherson, as documented by state investigators and Clearwater police."
  • Church, critics may share path
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 3, 1998
    "In what is fast becoming a local tradition, the Church of Scientology and its critics again are trying to outmaneuver each other in preparation for a series of anti-Scientology pickets this weekend in downtown. The result in recent days has been an unusual game of chess played on the concrete squares of downtown's public sidewalks. "
McPherson relatives lead protest
St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 6, 1998

CLEARWATER -- Relatives of Lisa McPherson made a tear-filled trip Saturday night to the Scientology hotel where she spent her final days under guard and in the grips of a mental breakdown.

Her aunt and uncle, Dell and Art Liebreich, and her cousin Kim Krenek led a group of about 60 anti-Scientology protesters who held candles and laid a wreath outside a privacy wall at Scientology's Fort Harrison Hotel. A few feet away, just beyond the wall, was Room 174, where McPherson is said to have spent 17 days under the care of fellow Scientologists.

She died at 36 on Dec. 5, 1995, and the Church of Scientology was criminally charged last month with abuse and practicing medicine without a license.

As Dell Liebreich and Krenek wept, a Scientology staffer wrote down license plate numbers of protesters who had parked nearby. And church spokesman Brian Anderson released a written statement saying in part: "These protesters did not and do not care about Lisa McPherson. The proof is this: They are showing no love or kindness for any of the thousands of church members who live in and are continuing to serve this community as Lisa once did."

McPherson's family has filed a wrongful death lawsuit that contends Scientology's procedures regarding mentally disturbed parishioners are what killed her.

The church contends Dell Liebreich was a disengaged relative who was not interested in McPherson when she was alive and who engineered the lawsuit to cash in on her death.

Dell Liebreich and Krenek are among McPherson's closest surviving relatives. Her mother, Fannie McPherson of Dallas, died shortly after the lawsuit was filed in 1997.

Told of the church's statement Saturday, Liebreich said, "The protesters care a lot more about her than they (Scientologists) did. . . . They did nothing but torture her."

McPherson was guarded, kept from licensed medical care, held down and forced to swallow food and medicine, according to documents in the civil and criminal cases against Scientology.

Saturday marked the first time McPherson's family had been to the Fort Harrison. They traveled from Texas for the ceremony, which also was attended by many of Scientology's most determined critics.

Liebreich thanked them and others around the world who have expressed support for the family. Krenek wore a locket with McPherson's picture. A bagpiper played Amazing Grace. The family held close to a private security team.

The evening vigil followed a day of picketing by the critics in downtown Clearwater as hundreds of Scientologists stayed off the streets.

Visiting parishioners and church staffers were ferried between Scientology's buildings in rented vans with dark tinted windows and holiday decorations. When protesters came near, staffers ran into church buildings, which were fortified in several ways.

A 5-foot-high masonry wall surrounding much of the Fort Harrison Hotel was made three feet higher with temporary lattice and cardboard. A row of Christmas trees blocked views at another Scientology hotel. Many entrances were blocked from view.

"The church and its members have made an active effort during this week to avoid any sort of confrontation with protesters, despite having been taunted and baited continuously," Scientology said in a statement.

About two dozen police officers monitored the protest, which was held without incident.

The church's defensive posture contrasted with its history of counterattack. At a similar protest early last year, Scientologists surrounded the pickets, taunted them, blocked their signs and blew out their candles. In response to another picket last December, about 3,000 Scientologists surrounded the Clearwater Police Department in an angry march that irritated city officials.

Their only offensive this year was verbal. In its statement, Scientology called the protesters a small group of "biased and slanted" critics who "don't represent the views of this community."

The only obvious presence of Scientologists on Saturday was on the roof of the Fort Harrison, where about 20 church staffers installed giant red letters atop the old hotel's graceful facade. The words read: "Happy Holidays!"


DECEMBER 5-7, 1997

The third Clearwater picket started the tradition of staging the event around the date of Lisa McPherson's death. This time around, the cult kept its public members away from the protesters, but still had all of its intelligence agents and private investigators out on the streets, photographing and filming everyone. There were even cameras hidden in the gingerbread houses of Scientology's "Winter Wonderland", which was set up across the street from the Ft. Harrison.

The public Scientologists were busy staging their own protest - several thousand of them marched around the Clearwater Police Department and the St. Petersburg Times. The demonstration angered city officials and brought back memories of Scientology's earlier and more hostile years in Clearwater.

  • Talk of the Bay
    WMNF 88.5 FM, Dec. 4, 1997

    Rob Lorei interviews former Scientologists Martin Ottman, Arnie Lerma, and Birgitta Dagnell, with CoS PR shill Sylvia Stanard.

  • News Articles and Letters

    Letter to the Clearwater City Manager
    Mark Dallara, Nov. 30, 1997
    "In summary, the accusations by the the cult are naught but a desperate attempt to interfere with a peaceful protest against their unethical and unlawful tactics... The safest route for the city government and the demonstrators is to keep the permits in place and maintain a visible and vigilant police presence at the events."

    Scientologists ask city to block picketing
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 1, 1997
    "The protesters are a group of Scientology critics from around the country who communicate on the Internet. Some oppose the church's practices and the tactics it takes against critics. Others base their opposition on what they say is an effort by the church to censor what is said about Scientology on the Internet."

    The hypocrisy of Scientology
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 2, 1997
    "What is outrageous is the Church of Scientology's hypocrisy. When it suits them, Scientologists claim to be the persecuted minority trying to exert their constitutional rights. In this case, it suits them to deprive other citizens their free speech. "

    Protest gets green light
    Tampa Tribune, Dec. 2, 1997
    "The city has denied a request to ban anti-Scientology protesters from certain downtown sidewalks. Demonstrations are planned this weekend in front of the Church of Scientology's downtown retreat to protest the death of church member Lisa McPherson two years ago."

    Thousands turn out for Scientology
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 6, 1997
    "Klein said Friday night's protest reminded him of the day in 1981 when a much smaller group of church members picketed the Times and the now-defunct Clearwater Sun in Nazi uniforms to protest the newspapers' coverage."

    Critics, church stage protests
    Tampa Tribune, Dec. 6, 1997
    "Klein dismissed the accusations as absurd and demanded the church produce evidence that police were doing anything other than investigating a suspicious death."

    Protesters picket Church of Scientology
    Tampa Tribune, Dec. 7, 1997
    "Scientologists took numerous photographs of the protesters in front of the church's religious retreat, the Fort Harrison Hotel. But they didn't face off with the demonstrators as they did in March, when about 300 turned out to counter-protest about 30 anti-Scientologist demonstrators."

    Clearwater chief has earned his city's support
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 9, 1997
    "Scientology leaders tried to pressure the city into closing the sidewalk in front of their building to the demonstrators, warning that a church meeting and the opening of Winter Wonderland would expose thousands of visitors to potential violence. City officials refused to close the sidewalk but agreed to separate demonstrators from Scientologists with barricades. All Americans have the right to public protest as long as they don't violate the rights of others."

    Clearwater reacts to church's attacks
    St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 9, 1997
    "The church's anti-Klein initiative began Friday night as a group of about 30 protesters demonstrated in memory of Lisa McPherson, the Scientologist who died in 1995 while in the care of fellow church members. That evening, an estimated 3,000 to 4,000 Scientologists demonstrated at police headquarters, and church officials wrote Klein saying he had discriminated against the church by aiding the protesters."

    Scientology's Tactics
    Letter to the St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 16, 1997
    "If there was any doubt that Scientology is still a dangerous and deceitful organization, last week's events have erased it. The cult's baseless attacks on the protesters, police department, and press have shown that yes, Clearwater is still in a war of information with the cult of Hubbard."

    Church retaliates against Davis Sq. critic
    Sommerville Journal, Dec. 18, 1997
    "Newman, who two years ago posted a Web site detailing what he calls attempts by the church to suppress critics, believes several dozen fliers were distributed while he was at a Clearwater, Fla., demonstration at the church's headquarters."

The hypocrisy of Scientology
St. Petersburg Times, Dec. 2, 1997

In the past, the Church of Scientology has defended its actions by claiming the First Amendment right of free speech. Now, it would deny that constitutional right to its critics by stopping them from picketing in front of the church's main building in downtown Clearwater.

Scientology can't have it both ways.

A group of 20 to 30 protesters has planned a non-violent demonstration in front of the former Fort Harrison Hotel, now Scientology's spiritual headquarters, to mark the second anniversary of Lisa McPherson's death.

McPherson was a 36-year-old Scientologist who suffered an emotional breakdown in November 1995 after a minor traffic accident. Instead of accepting medical and psychiatric care, McPherson went back to the Fort Harrison building and was placed in isolation. Seventeen days later, on Dec. 5, 1995, she was taken by Scientologists to a New Port Richey emergency room where resuscitation efforts failed and she was pronounced dead.

An autopsy by the medical examiner showed the cause of death to be a blood clot brought on by severe dehydration and prolonged bed rest. Clearwater police are wrapping up a criminal investigation of McPherson's death, and State Attorney Bernie McCabe will decide whether to file criminal charges.

The protesters, some of them former Scientologists, wanted to mark McPherson's death with demonstrations on the evening of Dec. 5 and during the day of Dec. 6. They planned to carry signs on the sidewalks in front of the Fort Harrison building.

Although the protesters didn't need a city permit, they applied for one and it was granted. Scientologists responded by attempting to have the sidewalks in front of their building closed off by police on those two days, saying a Christmas event called Winter Wonderland and a church meeting would draw thousands of visitors. Scientologists claimed the protesters had been involved in violence against the church, but offered no substantial proof.

Clearwater Police Chief Sid Klein denied the Scientologists' request, saying he had no proof of violent behavior by the protesters. In a letter to Clearwater City Manager Michael Roberto, Scientology director Ben Shaw said "actions such as this give us the feeling of being treated as second-class citizens by the city police."

After Scientology's heavy-handed effort to close down a public sidewalk, it is the protesters who should feel like second-class citizens.

In the Scientology letter, which asks Roberto to overrule Klein and close the sidewalks, Shaw writes: "Chief Klein's insistence that the rights of a dozen protestors from outside Clearwater supersedes the rights of thousands of Clearwater citizens is, in my judgment, outrageous."

What is outrageous is the Church of Scientology's hypocrisy. When it suits them, Scientologists claim to be the persecuted minority trying to exert their constitutional rights. In this case, it suits them to deprive other citizens their free speech.

Roberto should not let the Church of Scientology bully him. Clearwater police are fully capable of allowing the demonstration and maintaining the peace.


MARCH 7-9, 1997

Joe Neal, of Scientology's Office of Special Affairs
OSA agent Joe Neal filming protesters in Clearwater.

While the March '96 protest was focused on free speech and the Internet, the event the following year had a new central figure - Lisa McPherson. This picket was primarily characterized by the response of the Scientologists - roughly 300 of them were sent out to surround the 30+ protesters, harrass them, and hide their signs with the Scientologists' own signs.
  • Visit from Scientologists Bennetta Slaughter & John Carmichael
    Jeff Lee, (prior to Mar. 7, 1997)
    "BS: Okay. Maggie asked me, 'Was she on the Introspection Rundown?' She was not on the Introspection Rundown. There's another thing. You know, first of all, whatever anybody wants to believe it or not, you know, this -- this Del Liebrich that's helping to push this?"
  • Clearwater Picket '97 - One Suppressive's Report
    Jeff Lee, Mar. 8, 1997
    "Being a first-person account of a picket against the Church of Scientology held on 8 March 1997, and a candlelight vigil held in memory of Scientologist Lisa McPherson, who died while supposedly being cared for in Scientology's Clearwater spiritual centre."
  • Scientologists crash protesters' line
    Tampa Tribune, Mar. 9, 1997
    "About 30 demonstrators protested the Church of Scientology on Saturday, drawing about 300 Scientologists who protested the picketers. There were no reports of violence, but the accusations and verbal exchanges were intense."
  • Interview with Jeff Lee
    WFLA 970 AM Tampa, Mar. 10, 1997
    "They swarmed around us, they were blowing out our candles; they got even nastier. I was escorting a blind woman; one guy would consistently stand in front of her so that she would bump into him, and when she did, he would move over so he got between her and her guide dog so she would have to back up against the crowd behind her."

MARCH 8-10, 1996

The first Clearwater protest against Scientology in recent years was the epicenter of a worldwide series of demonstrations, organized and coordinated through the Internet. The global effort was a response to the cult's repeated attacks on the free speech rights of critics and former members, including raids on the homes of Dennis Erlich and Arnie Lerma, and multiple attempts to shut down and otherwise block the newsgroup alt.religion.scientology.

Paul Grossman picketing the Flag Land Base
Former Sea Org member Paul Grossman picketing in Clearwater
  • Picket Scientology March 9 in Clearwater
    Jeff Jacobsen, alt.religion.scientology, Mar. 4, 1996
    "In the past year, a pattern of harassment has developed against those who publicly criticize Scientology on the Internet, including lawsuits and threats of lawsuits, visits by Scientology-employed private investigators, and more.  Many at the March 9 picket are drawn to protest based on the ongoing and public harassment of Internet users.  Similar demonstrations by Internet users will also take place in cities around the world."
  • Clearwater Picket
    Jeff Lee, alt.religion.scientology, Mar. 9, 1996
    "More interviews with the media ensued; at any time that the press came near Steve Fishman, Arnie Lerma or Dennis Erlich, Scientology/OSA personnel (including Kendrick Moxon, Brian Anderson, Mike Rinder, Lynn Farny and Kurt Weiland) interrupted, attempting to harass and bullbait the critics... Steve managed to get in a good dig to Moxon, asking 'Weren't you an unindicted co-conspirator in the Mary Sue Hubbard case?' which rendered Moxon speechless for about ten seconds."

  • The Scientology Eavesdropper's Guide
    Ray Randolph, alt.religion.scientology, Oct. 27, 1999
    FAQ and frequency list for listening to Scientology radio communications in Clearwater and elsewhere in the United States.
FLAG SECURITY RADIO FREQUENCIES

Picketers at the annual Clearwater demonstrations against Scientology typically bring an impressive array of electronics, including radio scanners. These are useful for listening to the cult security guards as they monitor every movement of the protesters and coordinate the vans which move the rank-and-file Scientologists around Occupied Clearwater without letting them see the opposition.

The list below identifies a number of frequencies licensed by the Scientology cult for use near the Flag Land Base. It may not be comprehensive or entirely correct - email corrections and additions to site developer. If you decide to monitor these or any other frequencies, be sure to obey all applicable FCC regulations and Florida laws.

Frequency Callsign Licensee Radio Service Code Location
464.3750 WPJJ838 Church of Scientology Flag Service Org. IB - Business Clearwater, FL
464.7750 WPJJ838 Church of Scientology Flag Service Org. IB - Business Clearwater, FL
464.9250 WPLI360 Church of Scientology Flag Service Org. IB - Business Clearwater, FL
467.9000 WPJJ838 Church of Scientology Flag Service Org. IB - Business Clearwater, FL
469.3750 WPJJ838 Church of Scientology Flag Service Org. IB - Business Clearwater, FL
469.7750 WPJJ838 Church of Scientology Flag Service Org. IB - Business Clearwater, FL

 


MORE LINKS

Copyright Tilman Hausherr 1999
In memory of Lisa McPherson


Mark Dallara | mdallara@kcii.com | PGP Public Key | Legal Disclaimer
Last Updated:
January 26, 2000
BACK » Occupied Clearwater